Who Is More Responsible For Their Demise Essay
, Victor Or His Creation Frankenstein By Mary Shelley Essay, Research PaperThe word responsible is defined as being accountable for, in charge, or being apt for one s actions. In the fresh Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, both Victor and his creative activity are to the full responsible for their ultimate devastation ; nevertheless, Victor is more apt for his ain tragic death. When compared through their self-inflicted remotion from society, their quest for cognition, and their functions of Godhead and creative activity are both non satisfied.
It is clear that both characters are well responsible for their ain tragic ruin, but when compared Victor is obviously more responsible than his creative activity.Victor and his creative activity both are responsible for their ain death because of their self-inflicted remotion from society. The creative activity farther removes and alienates himself from society because of certain incidents that he has experienced sing rejection and disaffection from society. The creative activity deserts himself into his hut and separates himself from society following the episode refering the rejection that the creative activity has felt from the cottage dwellers.
The creative activity s self-inflicted remotion from society is proven through his reaction to the rejection he has received from the cottage dwellers:I continued for the balance of the twenty-four hours in my hut in a province of utter and stupid desperation. My defenders had the universe. For the first clip the feelings of retaliation and them, but leting myself to be borne off by the watercourse, I bent my head towards hurt and decease.
( Shelley 123 )This transition depicts the badness of the creative activity s backdown from society. Although the creative activity s remotion from society is self-inflicted, the rejection from society and from the cottage dwellers cause the creative activity s continual disaffection and isolation from society. This isolation from society leads to the creative activity s overall devastation. Victor is clearly more responsible for his ain tragic ruin because of his ain self-inflicted remotion from society. Victor is more responsible because he removes himself from society to make his supreme being and ignores the demands of others to make so.
Victor is clearly more responsible for his tragic terminal because of his pick to take himself from society to make his being which leads him to a province of physical and mental illness. Victor is motivated to make so because of his yearning to be godly and to seek out power and control. Victor besides farther isolates himself from society following the calamity he has created. Victor s isolation from society continuing his calamity is clearly illustrated through this transition: Two old ages have passed in this mode, during which I had paid no visit to Geneva, but was engaged, bosom and psyche, in the chase brand. ( Shelley 35 ) This transition clearly lineations of how Victor is obviously more responsible for his tragic ruin than his creative activity because he removes and isolates himself from society.Victor and his creative activity besides portion the quest for huge sums of cognition, which leads them both to their tragic death. Victor is much more responsible for his tragic death because he seeks out great sums of cognition that can non be obtained.
This is proven when Victor is talking about his dreams: I entered.what glorification would go to the find if I could ostracize disease from the human frame and render adult male invulnerable to any but a violent decease! ( Shelley 26 ) Victor s illimitable aspirations of desiring to be god-like and his passionate thrust for knowledge lead him into the deepnesss of immorality, which leads him to his ain tragic downfall. This is turn proves that Victor is more responsible for his ain tragic ruin. The creative activity besides does seek out huge sums of cognition through larning how to socialise with other and besides larning to read. This is particularly important when the creative activity stumbles upon a bag full of books lying in the wood. The creative activity possesses a thrust for cognition which leads him to read these books and to finally read Victor s diary: It was your journal.Satan had his comrades, chap Satans, to look up to and promote him, but I am lone and abhorred.
( Shelley 115 ) This citation proves that the creative activity has a pursuit for cognition because of his wonder towards the books and Victor s diary. As a consequence of the creative activity s thrust for cognition he reads Victor s diary which forces him to seek retaliation on his Godhead, which leads to his tragic ruin. Although, both the creative activity and Victor are responsible for their tragic death, Victor is much more responsible because of his great pursuit for cognition.
The relationship between Victor and the creative activity is clearly non a typical male parent and boy relationship. The functions of the Godhead versus the creative activity are both clearly non fulfilled which leads to their tragic ruin. Although Victor is the more responsible party, the creative activity besides does non carry through his function as the creative activity in Victor s eyes. To carry through the function of the creative activity to his Godhead, the creative activity should look up to, seek cognition from, and love his Godhead. The demands that Victor expects from his creative activity prove that the creative activity has non fulfilled his outlooks or function as the creative activity. This is depicted when Victor is naming his hopes and outlooks from his creative activity: A new species would bless me as its Godhead and beginning ; many happy and first-class natures would owe their being to me.
( Shelley 39 ) The creative activity fails to accomplish the function of creative activity. As a consequence of the creative activity non carry throughing Victor s outlooks, he seeks retaliation and justness upon his Godhead and besides upon human sort. The creative activity is responsible for his tragic devastation because he fails to portray the function of the creative activity. In Victor s eyes, the creative activity is a entire calamity because it did non look or move like the ideal superhuman that Victor had one time dreamed of making. As the function of Godhead, Victor owes his creative activity a loving, lovingness, and supplying environment.
Alternatively, instantly after Victor infuses life into his creative activity, he abandons it, which is illustrated when Victor abandons his creative activity: Unable to digest the facet of the being I had created, I rushed out of the room head to kip. ( Shelley 42 ) Victor besides expects a great trade of satisfaction from his creative activity. Victor possesses illimitable aspirations towards the devising of his creative activity by desiring to be blessed by his creative activity.
Victor is clearly more apt for his tragic devastation because he has non satisfied the function the Godhead to his creative activity.In the fresh Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, both Victor and the creative activity are responsible for their tragic devastation ; nevertheless, when compared through their self-inflicted remotion from society, their thrust for huge sums of cognition, and their functions of Godhead and creative activity, Victor is clearly more apt for his ultimate tragic death. In society today, duty plays a big function in the mundane lives of people. Peoples must take duty for their actions and recognize that their actions will take them to either good or evil. Either manner it leads, that individual can ever be held responsible for the way they have chosen to their ultimate success or devastation.