The Jilting of Granny Weatherall Essay

Sometimes in decease. it makes people think about their life. In the short narrative. “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall. ” written by Katherine Anne Porter.

the chief character. Granny Weatherall is making merely that ; looking back on her life. In the movie made based on this short narrative Granny Weatherall besides thinks about her life. but as she is making things around the house. populating her life and non while being shut up in her bed. There are other differences that take topographic point between both the movie and the short narrative. But in the terminal they both tell the narrative of an old adult female named Granny Weatherall.The short narrative version of “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” has a watercourse of consciousness point of position.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

It is fundamentally Granny Weatherall. while lying in her decease bed. traveling over old events that had taken topographic point in her life as they came to her head and ideas. Granny Weatherall besides thinks about things that she is be aftering on making the following twenty-four hours. “The box in the Attic with all those letters tied up. good. she’d have to travel through that tomorrow. ” ( 17 ) .

That was Granny Weatherall believing to herself about traveling through some personal letters she did non desire Cornelia. her girl that she lives with. to happen.In the movie version of The Jilting of Granny Weatherall the viewing audiences get to see the narrative of Granny Weatherall in an nonsubjective point of position. The narrative is showed by Granny Weatherall really being out of bed and making things. While she is traveling about her twenty-four hours.

the movie shows us her ideas through small flashbacks Granny Weatherall has. Different from the short narrative. Granny Weatherall really goes up to the Attic and goes through the letters and Cornelia comes up at that place with her. There is besides some symbolism that takes topographic point in the movie that does non go on in the short narrative.

“What does a adult female make when she has put on the white head covering and set out the white bar for a adult male and he doesn’t come? ” ( 29 ) . Granny Weatherall thinks about this in the short narrative. but really makes a white bar in the movie. typifying her jilting and how she still thinks of it.

After reading the short narrative and sing the movie. I prefer the existent short narrative in the book over watching it. Reading it the first clip was a small confusing. But after watching the movie and so traveling back and reading the short narrative over once more. it makes enjoy the narrative so much more.

I now know that the narrative is told through Granny Weatherall’s ideas and so when I read I can acquire a better apprehension of who Granny Weatherall is. Besides. I believe that reading the last sentence of the short narrative the reader gets to bask a better position in their head so when what the movie shows.

“She stretched herself with a deep breath and blew out the visible radiation. ” ( 61 ) .Both the movie and the short narrative of “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” were great. The movie is easier to follow the first clip watched but the book takes the reader through Granny Weatherall’s interior ideas. They have some differences amongst themselves but they besides both portion the common subject of person believing about their life right before decease comes.


I'm Ruth!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out