Iycee Charles de Gaulle Summary The Controversial Issue Of Animal Ethics Essay

The Controversial Issue Of Animal Ethics Essay

, Research Paper

The Controversial Issue of Animal Ethical motives

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The battle against illness and disease is non over, yet medical advancement is being

threatened by militants who would stop the usage of research lab animate beings in the hunt for intervention

and remedies. Their well financed anti-research disinformation run is non the lone arm

used by carnal rights militants.

The more utmost carnal rights militants have used tactics of bullying and terrorist act,

for illustration:

April 26,1997, militants were arrested when they tried to coerce their manner into Yerkes

Regional Primate centre during a protest.

July 21,1997, The Animal Liberation Front ( ALF ) set fire to Cavel West, a Equus caballus rendition


July 5,1998, The ALF broke into a research lab at Cornell University and released tonss of

groundhogs into the wild. ( Americans for Medical Progress 2 )

These are merely a few illustrations of bullying and terrorist act that activists use to acquire their point

across. The animate beings used in those labs were all for ideal research lab carnal research. They were

non being used for decorative surveies. They were purely being used for medical intents. Some

things that they were in research for were to analyze liver malignant neoplastic disease, hepatitis, and to acquire tissues to

dainty skull born birth defects in kids.

In order to make up one’s mind whether these actions taken by militants are right or appropriate we

demand to reply this inquiry: Are the benefits of carnal experimentation worth the hurting that the

research lab animate being experiences? Once this inquiry is answered, the inquiry of whether animate being

Secor 2

experimentation is ethical or non will besides be answered.

The usage of animate beings in the life sciences goes back to ancient Greece and the earliest

medical experiments. To larn about swallowing, ancient doctors cut unfastened the pharynx of a

populating hog. To analyze the bosom they cut into its thorax. For centuries, doctors and research workers

used animate beings to heighten their cognition about how the assorted variety meats and systems of the organic structure

functioned, every bit good as to better their surgical accomplishments. As this cognition grew, new scientific

subjects were born. First physiology, and pharmacological medicine, and much later bacteriology, and

immunology evolved as carnal experimentation became more widespread. Table 2 depicts the

great springs carnal experimentation has provided to the human race. This timeline is cogent evidence of

great progresss gained from carnal proving for human benefit. Without proving or experimentation

of animate beings none of this would hold evolved. Human existences are non the lone species who benefit

from carnal proving. Table 1 depicts the progresss in biomedical research for animate beings. Without

carnal research worlds and animate beings would still be deceasing or wholly wiped out from these


Progresss for Animals

Table 1




Canine Parvo Virus

Feline Respiratory disease

Feline Leukemia





Heart disease in cats was eliminated supplementing diets with Taurine.

This besides prevented Feline Urologic Syndrome ( FUS )


A rapid and accurate trial now facilitates diagnosing of this insect-transmitted

disease. Heartworm medicine, besides discovered through carnal experimentation

is one of the most of import progresss in the history

Lime Disease:

Spread by ticks, this disease causes arthritis every bit good as bosom and Kidney jobs

in Canis familiariss. Animal research led to a vaccinum to forestall infection, every bit good as more

accurate diagnostic techniques.

Endangered Speciess:

Many endangered species have a opportunity of lasting thanks to biomedical

research on in vitro fertilisation and embryo graft techniques.

Beginning: Spouses in Research. ? Animals Benefit From Biomedical Research. ? hypertext transfer protocol: //www.pirweb.org/animals_do_benefit.htm ( 15, Feb. 2000 ) .

Secor 3

Table 1 Advances in Medicine Through Animal Research

Pre 1900? s

Treatment for Smallpox: Treatment for Whooping Cough:

One of the universes most dreaded A extremely catching respiratory disease

pestilences, estimated to hold caused characterized by short, dry coughs. Speciess

two million deceases. Speciess studied: cattles surveies: guinea hogs and coneies

Treatment for Anthrax: 1950? s

Disease marked by rise in organic structure temperature, Prevention of Polio:

followed by depression, spasms respiratory or A disease marked by symptoms runing from mild

cardiac hurt, paroxysms, and decease. infection to extended palsy. Today the disease has

Speciess studied: sheep been eradicated in the western hemisphere. Speciess

1900? s studied: coneies, monkeys, and gnawers

Cardiac Catheterization Techniques: Discovery of Deoxyribonucleic acid

A process which allows physicians to Determines single familial features.

infix a flexible tubing into an arteria or vena Speciess studied: rats and mice

to the bosom, used for shooting drugs straight Development of Open Heart Surgery and

into the bosom to mensurate blood flow and Cardiac Pacesetter:

force per unit area, diagnose and dainty inborn Revolutionized intervention for people enduring from

bosom disease and narrowed transitions. break up bosom disease. Species surveies: Canis familiariss

Speciess studied: Canis familiariss, coneies Development of Cancer Chemotherapy:

1920? s Can convey about remittal of certain malignant neoplastic diseases, either

Discovery of Insulin: short-run or for good. Speciess studied: monkeys

To command diabetes, a chronic disease of the coneies, and gnawers

pancreas marked by the inability to use 1960? s

saccharides, extra sugar in the blood and Prevention of Rubella:

piss, inordinate thirst, hungriness and micturition, An epidemic viral disease marked by low febrility, roseola,

failing and bonyness. Speciess surveies: Canis familiariss enlarged lymph secretory organs ; can do foetal defects in

1940? s pregnant adult females. Speciess studied: monkeys

Prevention of Diphtheria: 1970? s

An ague contagious disease marked by Prevention of Measless:

formation of membranes in the pharynx and An acute contagious viral disease, one time common in

other air transitions. childhood, marked by febrility and skin eruptions. Can

Speciess studied: Equus caballuss cause decease. Speciess studied: monkeys

Antibiotics: 1990? s

Development of penicillin and other antibiotics Breast malignant neoplastic disease links:

revolutionized the intervention of bacterial infection Scientists are shuting in on the familial and

in worlds and other animate being. Speciess surveies: environmental factors of chest malignant neoplastic disease, which is the

many including rats, mice and coneies taking cause of decease of American adult females ages

35-54. Speciess studied: fruitflies, mice, and rats

Beginning: Americans for Medical Progress Educational Foundation. ? Advances in Medicine Through Animal Research. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ampet.org/history.htm ( 7, Feb. 2000 ) .

There are many great advantages of carnal experimentation. But over the old ages animate beings

have been tortured. In order to forestall carnal inhuman treatment many Torahs and ordinances have been

passed. Some of the chief 1s are that unneeded duplicate of research. Reproduction of

experiments may be sensible, but the research worker must supply sufficient information to

justify why an experiment needs to be repeated. The figure of animate beings should be the lower limit

necessary to bring forth valid consequences and the research worker must clearly show the method where the

figure of requested animate beings was calculated. Last when its appropriate a non-animal replacement

should be used, or a species of lower order.

Secor 4

Animal experimentation has taken topographic point since before the 1900? s. As proven in the two

old tabular arraies at that place have been many progresss in medical specialty due to carnal research. Although

along the manner there have been draw dorsums. Misleading consequences derived from animate being experiments

have delayed of import medical progresss. A survey was done to happen compounds that would

cut down harm from ischaemic shot. There were 25 compounds that were proven to work on

research lab animate beings, yet none proved efficacious on human tests ( Animal Research is Wastefull

and Misleading 2 ) . Scientists believe that this is because the shot was all of a sudden given to the

animate beings. So they did non undergo the easy progressive arterial harm that normally plays a function

in human shots.

The battle against poliomyelits ( infantile paralysis ) was delayed due to misconceptions in surveies done

on monkeys. The experiments done on the monkeys indicated that the virus chiefly infects the

nervous system. When tests were done on worlds they found that the GI system

was the primary path of infection. The ground the primary path was different was because the


strains they had administered through the nose had unnaturally developed an affinity for

encephalon tissue. This resulted in ill-conceived preventative steps and it delayed the development of a


In add-on medical research is used in research labs to prove the safety of drugs and other

chemicals. The US Food and Drug Administration approved many substances that appeared to

be safe in carnal surveies. When subsequently used on worlds they were found to be unsafe to the

wellness of worlds. A few illustrations of these drugs are milrinone, which increases cardiac end product.

While this drug raised the endurance of rats with bosom failure, worlds on this drug had a 30 %

addition in mortality. The antiviral drug fialuridine was safe in carnal tests, yet it caused liver

failure in worlds. The antidepressent nomifensine had minimum toxicity in lab animate beings, but

caused liver toxicity and anaemia in worlds.

Although there have been some set dorsums, there have besides been many great promotions

in medical specialty which relied to a great extent on carnal experimentation. A premier illustration of this is the

Secor 5

infantile paralysis vaccinum. Albert Sabin studied this virus and introduced his unwritten vaccinum to the US in 1961.

Polio was a really deathly disease. This epidemic condemned 1000000s of kids and immature

grownups. In 1952, 58,000 kids were struck down entirely ( Sabin 1 ) . Without carnal research

Sabin would non hold had adequate cognition to contrive this vaccinum, and without this vaccinum

infantile paralysis would still be claiming 1000s of lives each twelvemonth.

The antibiotic penicillin is another illustration of an promotion that came due to animal

experimentation. In the 1940? s Howard W. Florey and Ernst B. Chain showed penicillin to be

dramatically effectual as an antibiotic by the mouse protection trial. Without this trial the this

of import antibiotic may ne’er hold been passed for human usage.

Another immense drug that is used in the mundane lives of many hunams is insulin. Before

insulin was introduced to worlds, people with diabetes typically died. Once the lifesaving drug

was tested on coneies and mice, worlds were able to utilize it and unrecorded with the disease.

The figure of animate beings used in the US per twelvemonth is hideous ( see table 3 ) . Although the

overall Numberss have reduced in the in the past 22 old ages. This could be due to the new Torahs and

ordinances that are invariably being passed, or to the oncoming of options.

Beginning: Scientific American. The Numbers of Research

Animals. http.//www.sciam.com/0297issue/0297trendsbox.html ( 16, Feb. 2000 ) .

As stated many times, carnal experimentation has led to great progresss in medical specialty, but

there are other ways to do great springs in medical specialty so proving these chemicals on 1000s

Secor 6

of animate beings. The most known options are known as the three R? s. They are refinement,

decrease, and replacing. These three options provide a manner to minimise carnal usage and

agony. Yet making this without compromising the quality of the scientific work being done.

While holding the ultimate end ever being to wholly replace carnal theoretical accounts.

Polish is one of the stepping rocks that will assist make the ultimate end. This is the

alteration of any processs that operate from the clip a animate being is born until its decease. This is

to minimise the hurting and hurt experienced by the animate being, and besides to better its wellbeing.

The experience of hurting and other emphasis is likely to ensue in alterations in the animate being which has

potency to raise the variableness of experimental consequences. With that in head it is in the best involvement

of scientists to guarantee that the conditions in the animate being house are the best possible. Minimizing

the hurting and hurt the animate being goes through, outputs better consequences. When the experiment is over,

the most humanist method of mercy killing should be chosen besides.

The following stepping rock is decrease. This is any scheme that will ensue in a reduced

sum of animate beings being used to obtain the same sum of informations. Making the appropriate design

and analysis of the experiment can increase the percision of the informations and besides enable fewer

animate beings to be used. Making a little pilot survey could besides bespeak whether or non it is appropriate

to travel into a major survey. This would extinguish immense surveies that yield bad or useless consequences.

The last stepping rock of the three R? s is replacing. A replacing is considered a

experiment that does non imply the usage of a whole, populating animate being. Replacement methods can be

used to wholly extinguish animate beings in a survey, or they will complement carnal experiments. Which

would cut down the overall figure of animate beings in the undertaking. Common replacings are computing machine

based systems, lower beings, and cell civilization systems.

The three R? s are great stepping rocks to wholly eradicate animate beings in experimentation? s.

Although Pan troglodytes? s Deoxyribonucleic acid is that best lucifer to human DNA. So it could be wise to analyze and

experiment on these Primatess. Our closest evolutionary cousins are Pan troglodytess. Worlds and

Pan troglodytess portion 98 % of our DNA ( Cramer 1 ) . The difference between the DNA of a human and the

Secor 7

Deoxyribonucleic acid of a Pan troglodytes can fluctuate from 99.6 % to 98 % . Another interesting fact about the similarities

in adult male and Pan troglodytes is the difference between human and Pan troglodytes is merely 160 enzymes ( Cramer 1 ) .

With this intimacy in Deoxyribonucleic acid we are able to see what will potentially go on to worlds when put

on a drug or whatever the intercession happens to be. The consequences may non be 100 % accurate due

to the 0.4 % to 2 % difference in DNA, but there is non a whole batch of room for mistake in this

section. So experimenting on Chimps Lashkar-e-Taibas scientists predict whether or non a drug will be

safe or effectual on human existences, and that can potentially salvage lives.

Through the information provided in this paper one can come to their ain decision on

whether or non carnal experimentation is ethical. Through my long difficult hours put into

researching this subject I have been able to come to my ain decision. I feel that the benefits of

carnal experimentation outway the draw dorsums of the disadvantages. Seen as how animate beings are

besides having remedies for diseases that are spread throughout their species, along with worlds.

That in my eyes is a much greater factor so the minimum hurting the animate being is put through. Its non

like there are no Torahs or ordinances put on company and scientists making these sorts of

experiments. So I say that carnal experimentation is ethical.

Americans for Medical Progress Educational Foundation. ? Advances in Medicine

Through Animal Research. ? hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ampet.org/history.htm ( 7, Feb. 2000 ) .

Americans for Medical Progress Educational Foundation. ? Animal Rights Terrorists

Target Medical Research Facilities. ? hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ampet.org/althits.htm ( 7, Feb.

2000 ) .

Americans for Medical Progress Educational Foundation. ? The Tragic Hypocrisy of

? Animal Rights. ? hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ampet.org/articles/article1.htm ( 7, Feb. 2000 ) .

Cramer, Guy. ? Familial Accounting. ? hypertext transfer protocol: //ytiles.com/accounting.htm ( 7, March 2000 ) .

FRAME. ? Alternatives. ? hypertext transfer protocol: //frame-uk.demon.co.uk/alternat.htm ( 31, Jan. 2000 ) .

IACUC. ? Concept and Methods To Limit Animal Use. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ahsc.arizona.edu/uac/iacuc/laws/concept.shtml ( 16, Feb. 2000 ) .

Marshall, Eliot. ? NIH Ethics Office Tapped for a Promotion. ? SCIENCE 284 ( 1999 ) :

1749- 51.

Murray, Dr. Joseph E. ? Animals Hold The Key To Saving Human Lives. ? Los Angeles

Timess. ( 5, Feb. 1996 ) .

Secor 10

Spouses in Research. ? Animals Benefit From Biomedical Research. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: www.pirweb.org/animals_do_benefit.htm ( 15, Feb. 2000 ) .

Spouses in Research. ? The History of Biomedical Research. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.pirweb.org/history.htm ( 15, Feb. 2000 ) .

Phillips-Conroy, Jane E. ? Field Primatology and Biomedical Research. ? SCIENCE 284

( 1999 ) : 1.

Sabin, Heloisa. ? Animal Research Saves Human Lives. ? The Wall Street Journal ( 18,

Oct. 1995 ) .

Scientific American. ? Animal Research Is Vital to Medicine. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.sciam.com/0297/issue/0297botting.html ( 16, Feb. 2000 ) .

Scientific American. ? Animal Research Is Uneconomical and Misleading. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.sciam.com.0297.issue.0297barnard.html ( 16, Feb. 2000 ) .

Scientific American. ? The Numbers of Research Animals. ?

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.sciam.com/0297issue/0297/trendsbox.html ( 16, Feb. 2000 ) .

Seachrist, Lisa. ? Lab Rats Still Not Animals. ? SCIENCE 264 ( 1994 ) : 1533.

Wadman, Meredith. ? Bid to Give Legal Protection to Laboratory Mice In US. ? Nature

393 ( 1998 ) : 6.

Secor 11

Wadman, Meredith. ? Legal Bid Could Extend US Animal Welfare Law to Cover Lab

Rodents. ? Nature 400 ( 1999 ) : 197- 98.

Wadman, Meredith. ? Population Explosion Raises Alarm Over Lab Animal Health. ?

Nature 391 ( 1998 ) : 623.