Rachel Doc Essay

Assess the validity of the following statement: In the 30 years after the Civil War, government policy towards Native Americans shifted from forced separation to integration into American society. The government did move away from forced separation, but not right away. After all, the Indian Wars of this time were focused on forcing the Native Americans onto reservations. However, toward the end of the period, the government did try to make the Indians more like white Americans through such things as the residential boarding school program. We must note, though, that this did not really make for integration into American society.The government was trying to destroy Indian culture, but it was not doing anything to actually integrate them into white culture. In the 30 years after the Civil War, although government policy towards Native Americans intended to shift from forced separation to integration into American society, attempts to “Americanize” Indians only hastened the death of their culture and presence in the America.

The intent in the policy, after the end of aggression, was to integrate Native Americans into American society. Many attempts at this were made, ranging from offering citizenship to granting lands to Indians.All of these attempts were in vain, however, because the result of this policies is much the same as would be the result of continued aggression. Beginning in the 1860s and lasting until the late 1780s, government policy towards Native Americans was aggressive and expressed zero tolerance for their presence in the West.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

In the last 1850s, tribal leaders and Americans were briefly able to compromise on living situations and land arrangements. Noncompliance by Americans, however, resumed conflict. The beginning of what would be called the “Indian Wars” started in Minnesota in 1862.Sioux, angered by the loss of much of their land, killed 5 white Americans. What resulted was over 1,000 deaths, of white and Native Americans. From that point on, American policy was to force Indians off of their land. American troops would force Indian tribe leaders to accept treaties taking their land from them. Protests or resistance by the Indians would result in fighting.

On occasion, military troops would even lash out against peaceful Indians. Their aggression became out of control. Indian policy gradually shifted from this aggressive mindset to a more peaceable and soft line policy.The Indian Wars ended in 1980 with the Battle of Wounded Knee. The battle resulted in over 200 deaths, but also, almost officially, marked a change in Indian policy. Although the change had subtly began before then, policies then became more kind. The Peace Commission created the reservation policy, although this was created 27 years before the Battle at Wounded Knee. The Dawes Severalty Act of 1887 was the greatest of reform efforts.

The Act provided the granting of land holding to individual Native Americans, replacing communal tribal holdings.Another policy, the Burke Act of 1906, allowed Indians to become citizens if they left their tribes. Citizenship was eventually granted to all Native Americans in the 1920s. Although the intentions of Indian policy shifted, the outcomes of these policies still helped to suppress Native Americans and their culture.

The policies, created by philanthropic reformers with good intentions, had reverse effects and actually helped eliminate Native Americans. The reservation policy obviously did nothing to prevent or qualm to fighting of the Indian Wars.The Dawes Severalty Act also had numerous negative effects on Native Americans. It broke up many reservations and lost a lot of Indian lands to whites. Within decades following the passage of the act, the vast majority of what had been tribal land in the West was in the hands of whites. Policies like the Burke Act helped the death of Native American culture, with Indians leaving their tribes in order to obtain American citizenship. So although numerous policies were created to benefit and save the Native Americans, these policies did nothing to help them and the Indians gradually died out, along with their culture.The aggressive policy towards Native Americans received a lot of criticism for Easterners and politicians.

This did bring about a change in policy. Although the policies were less bloody, they did very little to alleviate the problems Native Americans were faced with, and many times exacerbated the problems. The policy and attitude of forced separation was clearly volatile, however, the new policies had a lot of the same effects. Native American integration into American society was attempted, but unsuccessful.

x

Hi!
I'm Ruth!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out