Poem comparasion Essay
Sculpted from the very beginning a sense of loss and sadness is brought forth throughout Jane Weir’s heart wrenching poem “Poppies.
” Whilst her son is away- fighting in a battle for the gratification of his country- a mother at home depicts through memories the loneliness and grief war has caused her. Although, Away from the wretchedness of the battlements ,Jane Weir expresses how the feelings of those left at home can be just as traumatic as those involved in conflict. Pulling at your emotions Jane echoes the mother’s poignant words that express her true essence towards war and the dispute of her motherly creeds.
In contrast to “poppies” Wilfred Owen’s poem “futility” has a dissimilar approach to how the feelings of loss and sadness are conveyed. In “futility” Wilfred Owen describes the grievances of losing a companion as well the worthlessness of war. Being a characteristic poem Wilfred leaves the speaker unidentified; however it is believed to be a soldier mourning over the lifeless body of their associate whom in which died in battle.
Throughout the majority of the poem, the speaker is questioning the suns ability to provide energy and breathe life into the motionless soldier.Reflecting very much Owens own personal experiences at war the aim of his poem is believed to convey sorrows of war and effectively define war as a pointless act that will lead to many peoples devastation. Form and structure is conveyed majestically throughout Owens poem “Futility”. With fourteen lines Owens poem traditionally follows the form of a sonnet however, cleverly splitting it into two free standing seven line stanzas, Owen unexpectedly discontinues this trait. This gives the reader an appreciation of the unsettlement the loss of a companion can cause to a solider in the brutal situations of war. Owens careful use of punctuation helps to seep through the sadness that is felt during battlement. His use of dashes not only emphasises the life and helplessness of the desolate soldier, but also prolongs the sentences as though the life of the dying soldier is longing to be prolonged too.
In the same manner as Wilfred Owen’s poem “Futility” Jane weir has chosen the form of an elegy to express her poem “Poppies”. Likewise to “Futility” Jane weir has portrayed the sense of unsettlement through the form and structure used in her poem. The poem appears to have a strong regular sense of form however, we can also see a great amount of movement within this regular form.Many of the lines within “poppies” have breaks in the middle of them – mainly marked by commas or in some extreme occasions a full stop. This careful depicted variation suggests that the inner emotion of the mother, who is trying to remain calm and refrained, is breaking down with a rage of sadness growing inside. A strong use of motherly language comes pouring through Jane weirs poem “Poppies”. We feel the closeness between mother and child the moment she kneels down to pin the poppy to the lapel.
Jane weir- being a textile designer- very much embeds words such as “ornamental stitch” in her poem to incorporate her own use of language. Whilst, her poem focuses greatly on the feelings of an agonised mother, by spitting in words such as “spasms”, “disrupting” and “blockade” Jane Weir may also be recalling to the events that cause feelings of sadness and loss in this case the violence of his death. Similarly to Jane Weir Wilfred Owen uses his own personal experiences to reflect the language used throughout futility.
The feelings of loss and sadness are brought forth by the sophisticated language used to construct his commemoration for the dying soldier. Wordplay plays a major role throughout Owens’ poem. “Move him into the sun” gives a direct address to reader the reader and automatically engages them by throwing them into the present tense. Whilst Owen uses the present tense to dag the reader straight into the action, he makes a strenuous link between the past and present . I believe this is done to express how even now many years after the war it is still affecting the feelings of many who have experienced a loss in battle.Cleverly, Jane Weir uses imagery to pull the reader deep into her poem giving them the chance to fully emphasise with the feelings and emotion of the heart wrenching mother. Strongly by using the word “blockade” the sense of the mother blocking out the loss of her son comes tumbling forth.
Linking into this image of the mother blocking out the memory of her sons violent death with a sweeter, purer memory that is sustained in the second stanza, “selotape bandaged around my hand.” This picture also carries echoes of battlement injury as well as just cleaning the cat hairs off his blazer. A great contrast between the death in battle and the domestic happiness (the boy cuddling his cat) is powerful. Feelings of loss and sadness are expressed through Suggestions of religion in Futility. Was it for this clay grew tall? This is suggesting that the fury of Owen has got the better of him and now he has begun tearing away at his inner emotions and questioning the true meaning of life. He is asking that through everything mankind has been through was it for this turmoil of death that that life itself grew tall? Deeply reaching out for the sign of god Owen could be expressing his anger through this question by depicting the fact that if Jesus was rose again how can you, the most powerful organism in the world, not bring back these desolate soldiers back. This would compare to the mother blocking out her son’s death in “Poppies” as god is blocking out the loss of soldiers at war. “Seeds” and “sides” a few of the pararhyms included in Futility.
I believe Owen has encrypted this slight rhyme to give a false sense of security and tradition. This is done to reflect on the fact that the poem is not perfect , nor is the life of the bereaved soldiers in battlement. In comparison, Jane weir has gone down the route of a free verse. She has done this to re-establish the Controlling thoughts and memories of the mother and to express that there is little structure and her mind is all over the place.Jane Weir depressingly brings forth tone in her poem poppies.
Remembrance and grief are expressed in the first part of the poem as the memories of her son come flooding in bursting through the jaw strings to her heart, but towards the end of the poem the tone starts to become more calm and peaceful as the mother has accepted the grief of her son. From the beginning of his poem Wilfred Owen introduces a tone of hope and willingness however, this is not the case for long. Slightly, the tone begins to change and hints of desperation are brought forth. In the mind of Wilfred owen all barrels are gunning here showing his true emotions towards war. Pure anger.
As the poem progresses so does the darkness of his tone until towards the end an angry, unpleasant tone is set out. The poets own personal message is extremely important to their poem. I believe that Jane Weir focuses on the agonising pain that mothers of sons at war go through every day worrying and grieving over their freed loved ones fighting to live another day at battle. Personally, to me as a reader I think the main message that Jane Weir is putting across is that although usually forgotten and in the mist friends and family (especially mothers) left at home suffer just as much as the solders fighting in battlement themselves. Owens strong anti-war message is expressed from the very begging of his poem.
Despite the fact that Owen Obviously appears to be against war and has many attachments to god, one of the main messages brought forth in his poem is that how ever much you try to be loyal and hold tight to your religion something , in this case war will interrupt in your thoughts. To sum up his message Owen is stating that war is not for mankind, why take the trouble to evolve this far if all you end up with is innocent deaths at within battlement. To conclude in my view both Jane Weir and Wilfred Owen gave me a different approach to how war can be expressed.
Through the sophisticated language used to the personally heart touched moments the poems really connect both visually and mentally to the reader. I have enclosed the messages of these poems and they both have questioned my view of war. However with this all in mind, Wilfred Owens’ poem Futility boldly stands out. This being because I believe that his own personal experiences at war himself help to give his poem the edge and make it more realistic.