Jp Morgan Chase And Washington Mutual Commerce Essay

A A A A A A A A A Organizational Culture is defined as “ the system of shared actions, values and beliefs that develops within an organisation and guides the behaviour of its members ” ( Schermerhorn, Hunt & A ; Osborn 2008, p. 364 ) .A Taking this into history, we decided to look at JP Morgan Chase and Washington Mutual Bank and analyze what sort of organisational civilization exists in each company and find the differences.A With the death of Washington Mutual in 2008, the analysis is a spot after the fact, nevertheless, looking at their organisational civilization and comparing it to that of JP Morgan Chase we can possibly larn from Washington Mutual ‘s ruin.

We have to inquire, was there a dislocation in Washington Mutual ‘s organisational civilization that caused the behaviour of its members to alter and take the bank down the route to eventual acquisition by JP Morgan Chase? A What makes JP Morgan Chase so strong? Does JP Morgan Chase have a successful organisational civilization that carries them through even in the tough times? A How does the organisational civilization of JP Morgan Chase comparison to Washington Mutual ‘s civilization? These are some of the inquiries we will look at farther on.

Amalgamations are nil new to the universe of concern ; countless of concerns have been acquired, bought out, phased out and bankrupted, along with other types of entity deaths. How is it that a company can last over 200 old ages and go on to be one of the largest Bankss in the universe while another dies in merely over 100 old ages?

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

In order to understand the organisational civilization of both Bankss we need to look at their background. Where did they come from and where are they now.

Historical Background of JP Morgan Chase

In 1799, the United States 3rd Vice President Aaron Burr created the Bank of the Manhattan Company. Under the pretense of “ providing the City of New York with pure and wholesome H2O ” ( Anonymous, 2005 ) during the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1798, Aaron Burr helped to force a clause after being awarded $ 2,000,000 for the ambitious undertaking underway. This was a cagey gambit to sell the water company to the metropolis and instantly turned itself to banking. This action opened banking privileges that helped forestall the monopolisation in the banking industry that existed in the banking and province of New York.

“ After an epidemic of xanthous febrility in 1798, in which caskets had been sold by itinerant sellers on street corners, Aaron Burr established the Manhattan Company, with the apparent purpose of conveying clean H2O to the metropolis from the Bronx River but in fact designed as a forepart for the creative activity of New York ‘s 2nd bank, equaling Alexander Hamilton ‘s Bank of New York. ” ( The Economist, 2000 )

The ferocious political and personal competition that existed between Vice President Aaron Burr and Secretary of the Treasury, Alexander Hamilton, led to the celebrated historical Burr-Hamilton affaire d’honneur that led to Hamilton ‘s decease in 1804.

Chase National Bank was founded in 1877 by banker John Thompson, whose boy went on to get down the “ 1st National Bank of the City of New York ” which is better known today as Citibank. Chase National Bank kept its name until 1955 when Chase became interested in the Bank of the Manhattan Company. A amalgamation proved to be non so easy since Aaron Burr ‘s clause was still in consequence, stale but still in drama. Banker John J. McCloy, who was one the “ Wise Men ” ( Isaacson & A ; Thomas, 1986 ) under President Harry Truman ‘s disposal, acquired consentaneous consent of stockholders for the bank to be taken over. When the trade was struck for Chase National Bank to take over the Bank of the Manhattan Company, McCloy became president to unify both concerns together organizing Chase Manhattan Bank. George Champion succeeded McCloy and working with David Rockefeller, the bank became known as Chase Manhattan Corporation.

Chemical Bank of New York was founded in 1823 by three gentlemen ; Balthazar P. Melick, Mark Spenser, and Geradus Post. Following the same maneuver that Aaron Burr used in 1798, they started the New York Chemical Manufacturing Company to bring forth a assortment of chemicals the same manner Burr used H2O. They so successfully petitioned the New York State Assembly to go a bank ; hence Chemical Bank of New York was born. ( “ Chemical Bank Company History: Chemical Banking Corporation ” ) . In the early to mid 1990s, Chemical Bank purchased both the Manufacturers Hanover and Chase Manhattan and became Chase Manhattan Bank.

In the twelvemonth 2000 the steamroller J.P. Morgan & A ; Company came into the image. By now, Chase Manhattan Bank had become one of the most successful Bankss in the United States, but they were still looking to spread out. An understanding was made and J.P. Morgan merged with Chase Manhattan Bank making JPMorgan Chase & A ; Company. This was a $ 650 billion amalgamation, merely 2nd to Citigroup ‘s $ 800 billion. ( McGeehan & A ; Sorkin, 2000 ) . However, it did n’t halt at that place ; Bank One and Bear Stearns & A ; Company came under the cross hairs of in the mid 2000s.

Historical Background of Washington Mutual

Washington Mutual was established in 1889 as the Washington National Building Loan & A ; Investment Association after the great Seattle fire that consumed the bulk of the concern territory.

The beginnings were modest, to be certain, but non long after its creative activity, Washington National made banking history. The association ‘s first loans were approved in February 1890, one of which was an amortized place loan, possibly the first of its sort in the United States. Washington National went on to O.K. more than 2,000 amortized place loans during the resulting 20 old ages, going a much-used beginning for place mortgage loans. ( Funding Universe )

Merely shy of the First World War about coming to an terminal, Washington National Building Loan & A ; Investment Association changed their name to Washington Mutual Savings Bank and began to harvest the wagess. “ The recast establishment boasted more than 16,000 depositors at the clip of the United States ‘ entryway into World War I and benefitted well from the century ‘s first heroic poem military battle. During World War I, Washington Mutual ‘s assets rose 68 per centum, entering a addition of more than $ 4 million, and existent estate loans registered an even greater addition, by 250 per centum. ” ( Funding Universe )

In 1930, Washington Mutual attained a agony Continental Mutual Savings during the beginning of the Great Depression. By the terminal of the 1930s to the early 1940s, Washington Mutual grew to about 100,000 depositors, one time once more profiting from another economic roar.

The Second World War brought much attending to Washington Mutual Savings ; selling about $ 30 million in bonds. Now, no alien to amalgamations, Washington Mutual Savings merged with Coolidge Mutual Savings Bank ( increasing sedimentations to $ 72 million ) . New Torahs and statute laws passed in the United States leting Washington Mutual to construct new locations and to turn rather quickly. Still, Washington Mutual Savings remained, as the expression goes “ under the radio detection and ranging ” until the sixtiess when it started to turn and spread out out of the Seattle country. Washington Mutual Savings began to raise superciliums in 1964 when they acquired Citizens Mutual Savings Bank which, was founded in 1902 as Citizens Savings & A ; Loans Society. Washington Mutual Savings did non halt at that place, before taking over Citizens Savings ; Washington Mutual Savings obtained Pullman Savings & A ; Loan giving the Washington Mutual Savings a presence known throughout Washington State. The rapid growing of Washington Mutual came under examination. Was Washington Mutual spread outing excessively fast and distributing themselves excessively thin?

By the 1980s, Washington Mutual Financial Group, a seasoned corporation was about 100 old ages old. Washington Mutual continued with their acquisition and amalgamation fling and after successfully purchasing Murphey Favre, Inc. and Composite Research & A ; Management Company, they remained silent for about a decennary operating in different countries of concern such as travel services, existent estate partnership, and commercial loans.

In 1983, Washington Mutual demutualizes change overing to a capital stock nest eggs bank and within six old ages, doubled its assets. Then, in the 1990s, a former Murphey Favre employee named Kerry K. Killinger, who had assimilated into the Washington Mutual environment, rose up through the ranks of Washington Mutual doing CEO in 12 old ages. This is when questionable concern patterns began to take consequence. The followers is a list of the Bankss that were acquired under his reign:

Commercial Capital Bancorp, California, 2006

Providian Financial Corporation, California, 2005

Alta Residential Mortgage Trust, California, 2000

Long Beach Financial Corp. , California, 1999

Industrial Bank, California, 1998

H. F. Ahmanson & A ; Co. ( Home Savings of America ) , California, 1998

Great Western Bank, 1997

United Western Financial Group, Inc. , Utah, 1997

Keystone Holdings, Inc. ( American Savings Bank ) , California, 1996

Utah Federal Savings Bank, 1996

Western Bank, Oregon, 1996

Enterprise Bank, Washington, 1995

Olympus Bank FSB, Utah, 1995

Summit Savings Bank, Washington, 1994

Far West Federal Savings Bank, Oregon, 1994

Pioneer Savings Bank, Washington, 1993

Great Northwest Bank, Washington, 1992

Sound Savings & A ; Loan Association, Washington, 1991

CrossLand Savings FSB, Utah, 1991

Vancouver Federal Savings Bank, Washington, 1991

Williamsburg Federal Savings Association, Utah, 1990

Frontier Federal Savings Association, Washington, 1990

These acquisitions over the old ages gave Washington Mutual an unprecedented growing. Just over the bank turning 100 old ages old, it was deserving $ 42 billion.

Killinger ‘s doctrine was quoted by the New York Times, “ We hope to make to this industry what Wal-Mart did to theirs, Starbucks did to theirs, Costco did to theirs and Lowe’s-Home Depot did to their industry. And I think if we ‘ve done our occupation, five old ages from now you ‘re non traveling to name us a bank. ” ( Goodman & A ; Morgenson, 2008 )

The Subprime Mortgage Crisis had a awful consequence in the finance industry, and Washington Mutual felt the brunt of its force. This sent everyone running for screen. Finally, the crisis led to the board of managers to taking Killinger as CEO in late 2008. The FDIC was dubbed as the receiving system of the largest bank failure in the history of United States. Before Washington Mutual was sold to JP Morgan Chase, “ Kerry K. Killinger earned a entire compensation of $ 14,364,883, which included a base wage of $ 1,000,000, a hard currency fillip of $ 0, stocks granted of $ 10,120,731, and options granted of $ 2,846,400. ) ( Equilar, 2007 )

Problem Statement

As stated antecedently, Organizational Culture is defined as “ the system of shared actions, values and beliefs that develops within an organisation and guides the behaviour of its members ” ( Schermerhorn, Hunt & A ; Osborn 2008, p. 364 ) Looking at Washington Mutual we see that a one time strong and dependable organisation has shifted it ‘s construction and organisational civilization to a more toxic format. The board of managers holding buried their caputs in the sand, allowed their Chief executive officer Kerry Killinger to alter the manner Washington Mutual conducted concern. When Killinger came on board he followed the shared actions, values and beliefs that Washington Mutual had established over the old ages. This was made possible by the cheque and balance system of the executive squad. As clip went on Killinger shifted the organisational construction without any resistance from the regulating board and eliminated the executive squad which had provided the cheque and balance system. Killinger split the bank into two divisions, consumer banking and mortgage banking. Along with the displacement in construction a new organisational civilization formed and a greed outlook began to take over. In the mortgage division, the value of doing money at any cost prevailed. In the local bank a more set back insouciant ambiance was developed trusting to excite clients into the “ friendly bank ” in hopes of deriving more mortgages. Washington Mutual had no defined concerns rules, codifications of behavior, moralss or board of administration. We shall research these issues further on.

Literature Review

Organizational Culture – What is it?

“ Peoples in every workplace talk about organisation civilization, the cryptic word that characterizes a work environment ; one of the cardinal inquiries when employers hire an employee explores whether the campaigner is a good “ cultural tantrum ( Heathfield, n.d. Organizational Culture A¶ 2 ) ” .

So what is civilization? A basic definition of organisational civilization “ is the corporate manner we do things around here. It involves a erudite set of behaviours that is common cognition to all the participants. ( Corporate Culture Defined n.d. A¶ 1 ) ” .

“ Organizational civilization is the workplace environment formulated from the interaction of the employees in the workplace ( Heathfield, n.d. Organizational Culture A¶ 1 ) ” .

“ Culture is the environment that surrounds you at work all of the clip. Culture is a powerful component that shapes your work enjoyment ; you work relationships, and your work procedures. But, civilization is something that you can non really see, except through its physical manifestations in your work topographic point.

In many ways, civilization is like personality. In a individual, the personality is made up of the values, beliefs, underlying premises, involvement, experiences, upbringing, and wonts that create a individual ‘s behaviour ( Heathfield, n.d. Your Environment A¶ 1-2 ) ” .

Schermerhorn, Hunt & A ; Osborn define organisational civilization as “ the system of shared actions, values and beliefs that develops within an organisation and guides the behaviour of its members ” ( Schermerhorn, Hunt & A ; Osborn 2008, p. 364 ) .A

In their article “ Uncovering Organizational Culture: A Necessary Skill for Athletic Trainers ( Hudson & A ; Irwin, 2010 ) , organisational civilization is besides defined as the combination of cognition, beliefs, values, behaviours, and patterns that influence the mode in which members of a group think and act ( Specifying Organizational Culture ( A¶ 4 ) ” .

Finally, Hudson & A ; Irwin cited Schein ( 2004 ) specifying organisational civilization as:

“ a form of shared basic premises that was leaned by a group as it solved its jobs of external version and internal integrating that has worked good plenty to be considered valid and, hence, to be taught to new members as the right manner to comprehend, believe and experience in relation to those jobs ( Hudson & A ; Irwin, 2010 A¶ 5 ) ” .

How is civilization created and what types are at that place?

Since organisational civilization, sometimes referred to as corporate civilization is the shared premises, values beliefs etcetera, it is common belief that foundation of organisational civilization start with upper direction, specifically the Board of Directors and the CEO. While organisational civilization besides embodies sub-culture, we are merely looking at civilization in the wide corporate sense. Any alteration or development of organisational civilization can non happen “ without the buy-in and committedness of the CEO ( Ferro, 2010 A¶ 3 ) ” .

Leadership needs to set up “ regard for the mission ( Goltz, 2009 A¶ 3 ) ” .

Leadership besides needs to “ develop their employees strictly and authorise them to work out jobs ( Goltz, 2009 A¶ 4 ) ” . Goltz besides stated that “ constructing a strong civilization requires engaging the right people, firing the incorrect people and pull offing the work environment. ( A¶ 9 ) ”

“ One of the surest ways to aline the civilization to the organisation ‘s scheme is to use leading patterns that are besides aligned. The leaders, at all degrees, need to cognize what the needed civilization is and so find ways of set uping patterns and processs in all operations that will closely reflect the coveted civilization. They besides need to function theoretical account the really behaviours they wish exhibited by everyone in the organisation and supply the necessary support to others that will enable them to work consequently every bit good. Particular attending besides needs to be given to all communications ( Corporate Culture Defined, n.d. A¶ 7 ) ” .

Organizational civilization “ can be created or reinforced through the usage of socialisation. Avenues for socialisation abound in maps like choice, arrangement on the occupation, occupation command, the measuring and rewarding of public presentation, and acknowledgment and publicity. Reinforcing a civilization can emerge through the narratives told and the folklore propagated and, most significantly, through the attachment to take of import values ( Corporate Culture Defined, n.d. A¶ 6 ) ” .

McNamara, in his book “ Field Guide to Leadership and Supervision ( 2000 ) ” , defined civilization as “ the personality of the organisation ( McNamara, as cited in Organizational Culture, n.d. A¶ 1 ) ” . McNamara went on to province “ Corporate civilization can be looked at as a system ( McNamara, as cited in Organizational Culture, n.d. A¶ 2 ) ” which can be broken down into several classs as defined by Jeffrey Sonnenfield ( as cited in Organizational Culture, n.d. A¶ 5-9 ) which are listed below.

“ Academy Culture

Employees are extremely skilled and tend to remain in the organisation, while working their manner up the ranks. The organisation provides a stable environment in which employees can development and exercise their accomplishments. Examples are universities, infirmaries, big corporations, etc.

Baseball Team Culture

Employees are “ free agents ” who have extremely prized accomplishments. They are in high demand and can instead easy acquire occupations elsewhere. This type of civilization exists in fast-paced, bad organisations, such as investing banking, advertisement, etc.

Club Culture

The most of import demand for employees in this civilization is to suit into the group. Normally employees start at the underside and remain with the organisation. The organisation promotes from within and extremely values senior status. Examples are the military, some jurisprudence houses, etc.

Fortress Culture

Employees do n’t cognize if they ‘ll be laid away or non. These organisations frequently undergo monolithic reorganisation. There are many chances for those with timely, specialised accomplishments. Examples are nest eggs and loans, big auto companies, etc. ”

There are besides maps of organisational civilization. External version and Internal integrating. As Schermerhorn, Hunt & A ; Osborn ( 2008 ) province, “ External version trades with making ends, the undertakings to be accomplished, the methods to be used to accomplish those ends, and the methods of get bying with success and failure. Internal integrating, trades with the creative activity of a corporate individuality and with ways of working and populating together ( p. 365 ) ” .

Organizational Culture alteration and failure.

Can there be successful organisational civilization alteration? Can organisational civilization fail?

In order for organisational civilization to alter it must be a “ shared duty, and to be successful, every member of the squad must play a function. No affair where one sits in the organisation, everyone has an impact on its cloth ( Ferro, 2010 A¶ 7 ) ” . In an attempt to better their organisation and alter its civilization, Ferro stated that “ they should hold taken a more aggressive attack to end those persons who impeded their ability to alter and no longer suit into the company civilization. They should hold worked more sharply with the changeless whiners and those with a sense of entitlement, training them on their behaviour. Negativity can hinder productiveness because so much clip is spent pampering these persons and does non let the acknowledgment of the impact these workers have on others ( Ferro, 2010 A¶ 8 ) ” .

Sometimes it is necessary to get down from abrasion and get down all over. “ If you want to alter the civilization, you have to alter the people ( Wines & A ; Hamilton III, 2009 p. 434 A¶ 2 ) ” .

“ In cultural changing, organisational employees by and large fall into three groups: ( a ) those who have signed on for the undertaking ; ( B ) the opposition forces ; and ( degree Celsius ) those that fall on the fencing who hesitate while they wait to see which side will predominate ( Wines & A ; Hamilton III, 2009 p. 434 A¶ 2 ) ” .

Any “ echt alteration in organisational civilization likely needs at least two parts: ( a ) organisational alterations such as a strong, well-funded moralss office endorsed and actively supported by the really top direction degrees with resources, power, and position ; and ( B ) new vocabularies empowered by new narratives conveying new values Wines & A ; Hamilton III, 2009 p. 434 A¶ 4 ) ” .

Work experiences can “ turn rancid because of corporate civilization and internal political relations ( Knox & A ; Butzel, n.d. A¶ 1 ) ” .

In fact, “ most civilization alteration fails non because clinicians and directors do n’t desire to alter, but because many times, leaders make the error of decreeing new procedures instead than listening to those in the rank and file who have their ain thoughts about doing things better ( Betbeze, 2009 p.19 A¶ 1 ) ” .

As we can see, civilization is built-in in any organisation. From procedures, narratives, myths, rites, values and premises, all has an consequence on the productiveness of an organisation. If upper direction allows a toxic civilization to organize the ultimate monetary value is sometimes the death of the organisation as seen with Washington Mutual.

Analysis

Although both of these corporations were improbably successful over their long history, their organisational civilizations were wholly different. By and large talking, East Coast based JP Morgan Chase herewith referred to as Chase, has a more disciplined, priggish and professional mode when carry oning concern. Chase is one of the oldest fiscal services houses in the universe with its traditional old school manner of concern that has been integral since its origin over 200 old ages ago. Chase has a defined set of concern rules which are split into three classs:

Aspire to be the best ;

Develop a first franchise in concern we operate

Be field- and client-driven, systematically presenting the best merchandises and services in a cost-efficient manner

Innovate, trial and learn

Create powerful trade names that carry a committedness of quality and unity

Execute Superbly ;

Demand and maintain strong fiscal subject, edifice for good times and bad

Create and keep a fortress balance sheet

Design and keep the best systems and operations

Eliminate waste and bureaucratism

Keep a strong system of internal administration and controls

Measure public presentation through a complete and balanced scorecard

Construct a great squad and victorious civilization ;

Operate with the highest criterions of unity

Train and retain great directors

Be unfastened and honest with ourselves, our co-workers, our stockholders and our communities

Get inducements right

Foster an environment for regard and inclusiveness

Give back to our communities ( JP MorganChase )

In add-on to the defined concern rules, Chase besides has a defined “ Corporate Governance Principles of the Board policy which outlines the duty of the Board of Directors. ( JP Morgan Chase )

“ The Board as a whole is responsible for the inadvertence of direction on behalf of the Firm ‘s shareholders. The chief maps of the Board are to supervise procedures for measuring the adequateness of internal controls, hazard direction, fiscal coverage and conformity with jurisprudence and the Firm ‘s codification of behavior ; to measure and find the compensation of the Chief Executive Officer ; to reexamine the Firm ‘s compensation and benefits plans and its sequence planning and diverseness plans ; to reexamine the major strategic, fiscal and other aims of the Firm ; to reexamine the Firm ‘s community-oriented activities ; and to put up managers and measure the construction and patterns of the Board to supply for sound corporate administration. The Board accomplishes these maps moving straight and through its commissions. ” ( JP Morgan Chase )

Chase continues puting up their organisational construction and civilization by holding a defined Code of Conduct Policy.

“ This policy is for all employees of Chase including the rank and file. Chase states “ Our unity and repute depend on our ability to make the right thing, even when it ‘s non the easy thing. The Code of Conduct is a aggregation of regulations and policy statements intended to help employees and managers in doing determinations about their behavior in relation to the house ‘s concern. The Code is based on our cardinal apprehension that no 1 at JPMorgan Chase should of all time give unity — or give the feeling that they have — even if they think it would assist the house ‘s concern.

The intent of our Code of Ethics is to advance honest and ethical behavior and conformity with the jurisprudence, peculiarly every bit related to the care of the house ‘s fiscal books and records and the readying of its fiscal statements. The duties of this Code of Ethics addendum, but do non replace, the house ‘s Code of Conduct. ” ( JP Morgan Chase )

All of the above stated constabularies and rules help further Chase ‘s organisational civilization. Chase promotes a traditional point of view when making concern and a strong work ethic fostered by their beliefs, values, shared actions and behaviour demands governed through these rules. It trickles down from upper direction to the rank and file work force and has been the anchor to the success of the concern.

Conversely, looking at Washington Mutual, herby referred to as WaMu and reexamining their history, we see that WaMu originally began with similar rules. Over WaMu ‘s 119 twelvemonth history, lasting the Depression and the S & A ; L Crisis, their traditional concern patterns carried them through the tough storms. In add-on to WaMu ‘s traditional concern patterns they had a history of friendly service that can be documented back to its really low beginnings. They were genuinely the first bank to allow a place loan in the United States back in 1890. This trait stayed with them until the FDIC pickings over. Washington Mutual invariably praised how good alteration is and it should be embraced. ( Washington Mutual Jobs ) WaMu was known at the “ Family Friendly Bank ” until 1999. ( Grind, 2009 )

In 1988, WaMu ‘s former “ head, chose the entrepreneurial optimistic Kerry Killinger to take the bank, but surrounded Killinger with other prudent, seasoned executives. ” ( Grind, 2009, A¶ 8 ) In the beginning of Killinger ‘s calling at WaMu, he adhered to a rigorous no-frills policy with each acquisition he made. Killinger ‘s support squad of top executives would maintain the concern of acquisitions turn overing and the procedure enabled the acquisitions to be accomplished successfully. ( Grind, 2009, A¶ 13-14 ) Then in 1999 “ at the tallness of WaMu ‘s growing, Killinger shifted WaMu ‘s construction and civilization and divide the bank into two independent units of consumer and mortgage banking. Soon thenceforth, the traditional concern patterns and household friendly services were thrown out and a “ civilization of unmitigated greed ” took over. ( Grind, 2009 ) In an attempt to further more concern for their consumer banking division Killinger instituted a more relaxed, insouciant, and independent atmosphere. This proved apparent when Washington Mutual started to open their “ occasio ” retail banking. “ “ Occasio, ” a Latin noun for “ favourable chance, ” represents a dramatic displacement from traditional bank subdivisions in expression, feel and service. Rather than directing clients out to the ATMs, Occasio takes its cues from cutting border retail merchants, utilizing an unfastened, welcoming environment and ace client service to pull people into the fiscal centre. The complete bundle is unlike anything else the banking industry is offering. ” ( Business Wire, 2001 ) .

Washington Mutual ‘s replacing of the drab, traditional visual aspect with the expression and feel of a modern-day retail shop was wholly unheard of. Walking into an environment where clients are greeted by casually dressed concierge greets them and so escorts them to the proper service location. Edward tellers were literally nonexistent, client audience countries were apparatus for opening histories or using for loans, and there were particular countries for clients to speak with a fiscal adviser to discourse assorted investing chances. This type of atmosphere in concern is literally absent in the East Coast. This lone feeds more to the West Coast work moral principle.

On the mortgage banking side, the executive in charge, Craig Davis took an aggressive attack to the mortgage concern. “ The direction displacement disrupted the system that had worked so good, had unwittingly eliminated the cheques and balances that existed with Killinger ‘s executive squad. ” ( Grind, 2009 ) The consequence was a development of faulty concern patterns. Agents and assessors were paid to blow up monetary values. Employees were made to portion in unethical actions and promoted unethical behaviour. They were told this is how it is to be done and they tried to non acquire in the manner of the executives. Peoples who should hold ne’er qualified for loans were push through the system and their loans were sold to the highest bidder. The riskier the loan the more money the bank would do and the “ Family Friendly ” bank was now non-existent.

So how did Killinger, the CEO of WaMu acquire off with altering the organisational civilization, which changed the beliefs, values and shared concern patterns that had been a portion the WaMu of the past 119 old ages?

As the expression goes “ A fish putrefactions from the caput down ” . ( Goltz, 2009 ) Where was the Board of Directors? As the literature shows everyone in the organisations must take part in the organisational civilization and any alteration. WaMu ‘s CEO Killinger showed a spot of the “ Baseball Team Culture ” outlook where employees are “ free agents ” who have extremely prized accomplishments. ” ( as cited in Organizational Culture, n.d. A¶ 5-9 ) Killinger operated as a free agent carry oning concern as he saw suit without much intervention. As Lightle ( 2009 ) provinces, “ The Board of Directors failed in their mission to protect the shareholders ” . ( A¶ 3 ) It is the board of manager ‘s duty to supervise the ethical values of the organisation they serve. ( Lightle, 2009, as cited in the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 ) WaMu ‘s board of managers had “ neglected to set up codifications of behavior, ethical guidelines, supervising plans and a corporate civilization that might hold prevented the deceitful Acts of the Apostless ” . ( Lightle, 2009 ) The board is “ the first line of defence as stockholder fiduciaries, to presume a proactive function in specifying the coveted organisational civilization and blessing schemes for accomplishing it. Once such schemes have been defined and approved by the board, it becomes direction ‘s duty to develop and implement specific policies and processs to back up those schemes. The duty of the board remains to supervise the effectivity of those policies and processs as portion of its rating of direction public presentation. ” ( Lightle, 2009 )

WaMu ‘s values changed and money became the valued object. Sing the Organizational Culture Inventory Circumplex which can be viewed in the appendix ; Killinger seems to exhibit some of the Avoidance Thinking Style which, “ reflects apprehensiveness, a strong demand for self-defense and a leaning to retreat from endangering state of affairss. ( Human Synergistics, n.d. Avoidance Style ) Killinger refused to accept that anything was incorrect with WaMu even when the marks were so strong. He merely kept trusting it would travel off even when members of his staff would convey it to his attending. In add-on to the Avoidance Thinking Style both Killinger and Davis the caput of the mortgage division showed marks of operating in the Power Thinking Style which “ reflects demands for prestigiousness and influence, and the inclination to compare self-worth with commanding others. Peoples with strong inclinations toward this manner dictate ( instead than steer ) others ‘ actions, seek to run everything themselves and handle others in aggressive and forceful ways. ( Human Synergistics, n.d. Power Style ) “ Killinger who one time stripped companies of executive fringe benefits, was now turning accustomed to them and as the faulty concern patterns continued and money poured in, Killinger began to encompass the furnishings of a Chief executive officer ” ( Grind, 2009 )

Solutions

After reexamining the civilization of both JP Morgan Chase and Washington Mutual, we have to inquire the inquiry, what could Washington Mutual have done to assist prolong them during the subprime mortgage crisis? Other than the obvious non come ining the subprime mortgage concern to get down with, we have come to the decision that the following might hold been utile in forestalling the alteration in the nucleus organisational civilization.

First, Washington Mutual like JP Morgan Chase should hold an actively engaged board of managers. It is the board of manager ‘s duty to “ set up codifications of behavior, ethical guidelines, supervising plans, and a corporate civilization. ( Lightle 2009 ) All guidelines should be published and presented to all new employees both rank and file and all direction at the clip of hire.

Second, Washington Mutual should set up the appropriate “ tone at the top ” and guarantee the adequateness of policies and processs for conformity with legal and ethical criterions. ” ( Lightle, 2009 ) As the literature suggests the enforcement of the policies and execution of organisational civilization falls to the CEO who makes certain low-level directors carry out and portion the values and beliefs of the company.

Leadership besides needs to “ develop their employees strictly and authorise them to work out jobs ( Goltz, 2009 A¶ 4 ) ” . The ability to work out jobs was taken off from the employee when Washington Mutual started prosecuting in faulty concern patterns.

Goltz besides stated that “ constructing a strong civilization requires engaging the right people, firing the incorrect people and pull offing the work environment. ( A¶ 9 ) ”

“ One of the surest ways to aline the civilization to the organisation ‘s scheme is to use leading patterns that are besides aligned. The leaders, at all degrees, need to cognize what the needed civilization is and so find ways of set uping patterns and processs in all operations that will closely reflect the coveted civilization. They besides need to function theoretical account the really behaviours they wish exhibited by everyone in the organisation and supply the necessary support to others that will enable them to work consequently every bit good. Particular attending besides needs to be given to all communications ( Corporate Culture Defined, n.d. A¶ 7 ) ” .

Organizational civilization “ can be created or reinforced through the usage of socialisation. Avenues for socialisation abound in maps like choice, arrangement on the occupation, occupation command, the measuring and rewarding of public presentation, and acknowledgment and publicity. Reinforcing a civilization can emerge through the narratives told and the folklore propagated and, most significantly, through the attachment to take of import values ( Corporate Culture Defined, n.d. A¶ 6 ) ” .

A large portion of doing certain employees have the right attitude to suit in with WaMu ‘s organisational civilization is the type of personality each employee has. Harmonizing to Schermerhorn, Hunt and Osborn ( 2008 ) “ There are two popular ways of categorising personality traits, the Myers Briggs Type Indicator [ MBTI ] and the Big Five Model ” ( p. 41,42 ) .

Contemplation and Decision

This has been an interesting journey looking into two good cognize organizationsaˆ¦ .

Mentions

AQUILA, A. ( 2009 ) . The losing piece in amalgamations. Accounting Today, 23 ( 17 ) , 41. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Anonymous. ( 2005, December 22 ) . “ Bank of the Manhattan Company Chartered 1799: A Progressive Commercial Bank ” . Retrieved 02 17, 2010, from hypertext transfer protocol: //infomotions.com/etexts/gutenberg/dirs/1/7/3/7/17374/17374.htm: hypertext transfer protocol: //infomotions.com/

BETBEZE, P. ( 2009 ) . Culture Panel: Beware the Land Mines to Change. Health Leaders Magazine, 12 ( 12 ) , 17-19. Retrieved from Health Business Fulltext Elite database.

Brodkin, J. ( 2009 ) . Complexity regulations internal clouds. Network World, 26 ( 31 ) , 12-32. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Business Wire. ( 2001, April 17 ) . Washington Mutual Announces Plans for Branded Retail Banking Concept In Atlanta ; ”Occasio ” … ” . Retrieved February 20, 2010, from www.all business.com: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.allbusiness.com/banking-finance/banking-lending-credit-services-cash/6102991-1.html

“ Chemical Bank Company History: Chemical Banking Corporation ” . ( n.d. ) . Retrieved February 17, 2010, from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.answers.com/topic/chemical-banking: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.answers.com

Coffin, B. ( 2009 ) . Come Together. Risk Management ( 00355593 ) , 56 ( 9 ) , 18-19. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Corporate Culture Defined ( n.d. ) . Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.sergaygroup.com/What-is-Corporate-Culture-.html ( February 5, 2010 )

Creasy, T. , Stull, M. , & A ; Peck, S. ( 2009 ) . Understanding employee-level kineticss within the amalgamation and acquisition procedure. Journal of General Management, 35 ( 2 ) , 21-42. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

“ Duel at Dawn, 1804 ” . ( 2000 ) . Retrieved February 16, 2010, from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.eyewitnesstohistory.com/duel.htm: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.eyewitnesstohistory.com/

Duska, R. ( 2010 ) . Pull offing for an Ethical Culture: What to Make with Tom? Journal of Financial Service Professionals, 64 ( 1 ) , 22-24. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Equilar. ( 2007, September 8 ) . “ Executive Compensation ” . Retrieved February 18, 2010, from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.equilar.com/CEO_Compensation/WASHINGTON_MUTUAL_INC_Kerry_K._Killinger.php: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.equilar.com

Ferro, S. ( 2010 ) . Making a Culture of Professional Engagement. Journal of Jewish Communal Service, 85 ( 1 ) , 195-199. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier database.

Funding Universe. ( n.d. ) . “ Washington Mutual, Inc. ” . Retrieved February 18, 2010, from www.fundinguniverse.com: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.fundinguniverse.com/company-histories/Washington-Mutual-Inc-Company-History.html

Goodman, P. S. , & A ; Morgenson, G. ( 2008, December 27 ) . “ Stating Yes, WaMu Built Empire on Shaky Loans ” . The New York Times, p. A1

Goltz, J. ( 2009 ) . Corporate Culture. Federal security bureau: Fortune Small Business, 19 ( 8 ) , 61. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Grind, K. ( 2009 ) . Turn in corporate civilization blamed for WaMu death. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //sacramento.bizjournals.com/sacramento/stories/2009/03/16/focus2.html ( February 10, 2010 )

Gustafson, J. ( 2009 ) JP Morgan Chase prepares to rebrand WaMu subdivisions. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.allbusiness.com/banking-finance/banking-institutions-systems-bank-branches/12287837-1.html ( January 30, 2010 )

Heathfield, S. ( n.d. ) . Organizational Culture: Corporate Culture in Organizations. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //humanresources.about.com/od/organizationalculture/Organizational_Culture_Corporate_Culture_in_Organizations.htm ( February 5, 2010 ) .

Heathfield, S. ( n.d. ) . Culture: Your Environment for Peoples at Work. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //humanresources.about.com/od/organizationalculture/a/culture.htm ( February 5, 2010 )

Henderson, M. ( 2009 ) . Why Culture Is King. New Zealand Management, 56 ( 10 ) , 23. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Hudson, M. , & A ; Irwin, Z. ( 2010 ) . Uncovering Organizational Culture: A Necessary Skill for Athletic Trainers. Athletic Therapy Today, 15 ( 1 ) , 4-8. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier database.

Human Synergistics ( n.d. ) Passive Thinking Style. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.human-synergistics.com.au/content/products/circumplex/passive.asp ( February 15, 2010 )

Human Synergistics ( n.d. ) Aggressive Thinking Styles. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.human-synergistics.com.au/content/products/circumplex/aggressive.asp ( February 15, 2010 )

Isaacson, W. , & A ; Thomas, E. ( 1986 ) . “ The Wise Work force: Six Friends and the World They Made ” . New York: Simon & A ; Schuster Paperbacks.

JP Morgan Chase ( n.d. ) . Business Principles. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.jpmorganchase.com/corporate/About-JPMC/document/business_principles.pdf ( February 5, 2010 )

Knox, D.L. & A ; Butzel, S.S. ( n.d. ) . What is Corporate Culture? Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.lifeworktransitions.com/monster/CorCul.html ( February 5, 2010 )

Lightle, S. , Baker, B. , & A ; Castellano, J. ( 2009 ) . The Role of Boards of Directors in Determining Organizational Culture. CPA Journal, 79 ( 11 ) , 68-72. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

MATTHEWS, D. ( 2010 ) . Trust Maine: Credible Leadership Delivers Results. Chief Learning Officer, 9 ( 2 ) , 28-31. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

McGeehan, P. , & A ; Sorkin, A. R. ( 2000, September 13 ) . “ Banking ‘s Large Deal: The Overview ; Chase is Reported on Verge of Deal to Obtain Morgan ” . The New York Times, p. A1.

McNamara, C. ( n.d. ) . Organizational Culture. In Field Guide to Leadership and Supervision ( civilization ) . Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.managementhelp.org/org_thry/culture/culture.htm ( February 5, 2010 )

Morse, J. ( 2009 ) . People Mergers. Credit Union Magazine, 75 ( 12 ) , 52. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

Nancherla, A. ( 2009 ) . The Corporate Culture Survival Guide, 2nd Edition. T+D, 63 ( 11 ) , 72. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier database.

Overbo, J. ( 2010 ) . Using Myers-Briggs Personality Type to Make a Culture Adapted to the New Century. T+D, 64 ( 2 ) , 70-72. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier database.

Schein E.H. ( 2004 ) . Organizational Culture and Leadership. 3rd erectile dysfunction. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass

Schermerhorn, J.R. , Hunt, J.G. , & A ; Osborn, R.N. ( 2008 ) . Organizational Behavior 10/E.A New Jersey: John Wiley & A ; Sons, Inc.

Scott, D. ( 2009 ) . Wise Words? Credit Management, 18-19. Retrieved from Business Source Premier database.

The Economist. ( 2000 ) . “ Soaking the Poor ” , 1.

Washington Mutual Jobs. ( n.d. ) . View Jobs for Washington Mutual. Retrieved February 20, 2010, from www.wamu.com/careers: www.wamu.com

WaMu: the right people for the right occupation ( n.d. ) Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //adamp.com/management/wamu-the-right-people-for-the-right-job/ ( January 30, 2010 )

Wines, W. , & A ; Hamilton, J. ( 2009 ) . On Changing Organizational Cultures by Injecting New Political orientations: The Power of Stories. Journal of Business Ethics, 89 ( 3 ) , 433-447. doi:10.1007/s10551-008-0009-5.

Appendix

Organizational Culture Inventory Circumplex

x

Hi!
I'm Ruth!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out