Direct Democracy Vs Representative Democracy Research Essay

Direct Democracy Vs Representative Democracy Essay, Research PaperDirect Democracy V Representative DemocracyThe term Democracy is derived from two Grecian words, demos, intendingpeople, and kratos, intending regulation. These two words form the word democracy whichagencies regulation by the people. Aristotle, and other ancient Grecian politicalphilosophers, used the phrase, `the governors are to be the governed & # 8217 ; , or as wehold come to cognize it, `rule and be ruled in bend & # 8217 ; .The two major types of democracy are Representative Democracy and DirectDemocracy.

Clearly the statements for and against each signifier of democracy areplentiful. However, it is my belief that theoretically, Direct Democracy is thesuperior signifier of political regulation. Due to jobs with in the direct democraticsystem, its usage as a practical signifier of authorities is non even thinkable.Therefore, in order for any signifier of democracy to map, RepresentativeDemocracy is the superior signifier of political regulation.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Jean Jacques Rousseau is considered by many to be the `Grandfather & # 8217 ; ofdirect the democracy theory. Rousseau & # 8217 ; s ideal society would be where thecitizens were straight involved in the creative activity of the Torahs which are to regulatetheir lives. He maintained that, & # 8220 ; all citizens should run into together and make up one’s mindwhat is best for the community and ordain the appropriate Torahs. Any jurisprudence whichwas non straight created by the citizens is non valid, and if those Torahs areimposed on people, that is tantamount to the people being enslaved.The citizens of a society must both develop and obey `the supremedetermination of the general will & # 8217 ; , which is the society & # 8217 ; s finding of thecommon good. It is non even thinkable that all citizens will hold on what goodis. Rousseau recognized this and accepted a term of bulk regulation.

Those whovoted against a policy which is found to be the best for the general, must holdbeen believing of personal additions, instead than the additions of the full society.The characteristic which distinguishes direct democracy from other signifiers ofauthorities is the thought of understanding and the key to understanding is treatment. Itis impossible to make an understanding without treatment, because it is non rightto believe that everybody will hold the same sentiment on all affairs. But, it isreally possible, that through treatment an understanding could be reached by allmembers. Representation, on the other manus allows a choice few to dodeterminations in their ain best involvement, which is non needfully the best involvementof the society.However, direct democracy is non the perfect method to bring forth a brotherhoodof the community. For a direct democracy to work, face to confront communicatingbetween all members of the community is needed.

The lone manner this is possibleis to run into in big groups. Due to the fright of high tenseness, many citizens& # 8220 ; will non take part in these big group meeting. So in order for these

& gt ; fearful people to voice their sentiments they must acquire together in smaller, lesstensenesss groups, where they are non as cautious to state as they wish to see happen.A direct democracy can merely work in a little group, so as a signifier of authoritiesfor an full community or state, direct democracy would decidedly neglect. Asthe rank increases, people become less involved. Once the rankreaches the size of a state, the engagement still exists, but is limited toevery bit low as it can travel.

Therefore in a state, any signifier of direct democracy is merelypossible in single communities.In order for a commission little plenty to run on direct democracyrules to hold any authorization at all, it must stand for a much larger group.Membership in this larger group is chosen by election, so the people still havea say in the opinion procedure. Since the swayers are selected by the people, theswayers should stand for what the public wants. Therefore, out of direct democracy, isborn a new signifier of authorities, the Representative Democracy.Representative democracy is non democracy in its purest signifier.

The chiefstatement against representative democracy is that & # 8220 ; No 1 can stand for me. I & # 8217 ; mthe lone 1 who knows what I & # 8217 ; m thought and no 1 else can stand for myviews. & # 8221 ; We have already learned it is besides impossible to stand for yourself.Through representation, chosen by the people, the hope is that all people willbe adequately represented. While everyone may non acquire all of their positionsrepresented all the clip, representative democracy should make a state of affairswhere most of the positions are represented.

Direct democracy is non impossible in all state of affairss, but in order forin to be the undermentioned two features must exist- The organisation mustbe local, ( limited in members ) and the sentiments of the members must be similarto each other. While these conditions are frequently found in a little organisation,when looking at a state, these conditions are impossible to run into.In a assorted society direct democracy would take to uneffective direction,unwanted inefficiency, and political instability. While In a representativedemocracy, the representatives rely on political via media to decide struggles,and develop policies that are flexible plenty to run into shifting fortunes.

The one time dominant Grecian civilization has become outdated and along with itwent the hope for a direct democracy system of authorities. The direct democracytheory may hold worked in the little Grecian towns of 500BC, but in big modernsocieties, it merely could non work. Which is why the representative democracywas started, which, while supplying the citizen with less chance forengagement, is ideally suited for regulation in modern times Therefore, clearly adirect democracy is the lone true signifier of democracy. However, if democracy is tobe is used in a modern society, it can non take its purist signifier.


I'm Ruth!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out