Assessment process within the probation and youth justice system Essay
The intent of this appraisal exercising is to analyze the appraisal procedure within the probation and young person justness system.
Such scrutiny will take topographic point on the footing of the instance survey provided of Irene Glover. In add-on to using the information provided in the instance survey and schoolroom activity, this appraisal will do usage of relevant literature on the issue of offender appraisal in peculiar, in add-on to wider considerations refering to the condemnable justness system in general.When set abouting an appraisal of this sort, a assortment of considerations are of import. In footings of supplying an effectual footing on which to roll up a pre-sentence study, anterior strong beliefs are evidently of paramount concern ( Farrell & A ; Calverley, 2005 ) .
As such, any effectual appraisal of Irene would ab initio be reliant on the appraisal of anterior condemnable activity. The first benefit derived from such appraisal is hazard ( Farrell & A ; Calverley, 2005 ) . Through analysis and greater apprehension of anterior condemnable activity, condemnable justness practicians are potentially able to bet on the possible hazard posed by an person, both to themselves and other people. Irene ‘s anterior strong beliefs clearly indicate a long association with offense and the condemnable justness system. Although many of the offenses which have been committed are comparatively mild in badness, Irene however has a record of condemnable activity which stretches from 1973 to 2008. As such, she could be viewed as a accustomed wrongdoer and therefore could surely present a hereafter hazard.
In add-on, condemnable justness practicians need to efficaciously account for the figure of other tendencies and indexs when the appraisal of hazard is undertaken. Farrell & A ; Calverley ( 2005 ) point out that the inclination to perpetrate offense is frequently inextricably linked to societal fortunes. As such, it is indispensable that any appraisal of Irene efficaciously account for such societal issues in a manner which provides the appraisal with a series of implicit in causes for her behavior. The schoolroom activity highlighted the grade to which Irene has suffered from disaffection. The fact that she still lives alone personifies the extent to which she is obviously missing close societal webs such as household, friends and community.
Comprehensively documenting and accounting for such implicit in societal phenomena is an indispensable constituent of transporting out effectual appraisal. Furthermore, if certain societal fortunes have served to negatively impact Irene ‘s behavior so this is surely a paramount issue for the future pre-sentence study. Although this assessment exercising is focused entirely on the assessment procedure as opposed to condemning, it is however of import to observe that underlying factors such as a deficiency of good societal webs are of import considerations non merely for the appraisal of Irene, but besides for possible future punitory action taken against her.When transporting out an appraisal of this nature it is critical that condemnable justness practicians take history of issues which may impact the persons ‘ actions ( Gibson & A ; Cavadino, 2008 ) . As suggested above, wider societal and social factors are of paramount concern ; nevertheless, it is every bit of import for practicians to account for personally related jobs which may supply greater apprehension of the condemnable Acts of the Apostless which have taken topographic point ( Gibson & A ; Cavadino, 2008 ) . Once once more, such appraisal offers the possibility of greater apprehension of the implicit in causes of the condemnable activity. In the instance of Irene, both the schoolroom appraisal and the basic information provided highlights the grade to which intoxicant has been a consistent job for a figure of old ages.
In peculiar, since 1993 a figure of the offenses committed by Irene have been alcohol related. Indeed, the present assault offense with which Irene may be charged occurred in the early hours of a Sunday forenoon, therefore it is most likely that alcohol played a portion in this offense besides. Therefore, the appraisal of possible hazard must take history of such jobs and the grade to which underlying alcohol addiction is moving as a direct contributory factor in Irene ‘s condemnable activity. Given this, practicians covering with Irene could potentially use appraisal tools such as inter-agency collaborative partnerships.
Gibson & A ; Cavadino ( 2008 ) suggests that since the mid 1990s the increasing focal point on multiagency coaction in societal policy has been given more prevalence. Therefore, medical professionals would surely work in concurrence with condemnable justness practicians in the preparation of the appraisal and subsequently pre-sentence study. On this footing it would so be possible to explicate a set of premises sing the extent of Irene ‘s intoxicant job and the grade to which it is impacting upon her behavior. Furthermore, such coaction would every bit affect other stakeholders such as societal workers.In add-on to the issues outline above, condemnable justness practicians would besides be required to look into farther issues associating to Irene ‘s status. As suggested above, societal webs and any drug related dependence would be of paramount concern.
However, in add-on it is every bit critical that issues associating to Irene ‘s working and life environment are addressed. The schoolroom exercising highlighted how the country in which Irene lives suffers from low degrees of development, high rates of offense and general hapless economic and employment chances. Understanding this background is of import for the appraisal foremost because it allows for an effectual opinion to be made with respects to further implicit in causes. However, in add-on it would besides be possible to project an appraisal of how Irene could develop in the period following strong belief. Therefore, the inclination to perpetrate farther offenses may be a consequence of the societal fortunes in which Irene resides. If this is so, so both the appraisal and pre-sentence study must take history of such factors.The appraisal of Irene must besides see the possible results of any sentencing. Once once more, although this exercising if chiefly concerned with appraisal as opposed to condemning, it is indispensable that the impact of old sentencing is examined in the appraisal procedure.
Krohn et Al ( 2009 ) point out that measuring old condemning action can give an indicant as to how the person has responded in the yesteryear to action undertaken by the tribunals. Furthermore, in recent old ages at that place has been an increasing willingness within the condemnable justness system to avoid tutelary sentences where possible ( Krohn et al, 2009 ) . In peculiar, low degree offenses such as those committed by Irene by and large do non ensue in prison sentences. However, it would surely be good for the appraisal to take history of the fact that old non-custodial sentences have done nil to change Irene ‘s condemnable dispositions. Therefore, a tutelary sentence may be appropriate. However, Krohn et Al ( 2009 ) point out that tutelary sentences for low degree offenses frequently result in the single gaining increased cognition of condemnable procedures whilst in prison as a consequence of being environing by more serious condemnable elements.
As such, this is besides a cardinal issue of concern, both for the appraisal and the pre-sentence study which follows on from it.Farrell & A ; Calverley ( 2005 ) suggests that in recent old ages increasing focal point has been placed on the extent to which the felon justness system itself serves to perpetuate condemnable activity. In peculiar, one key issue has been the mode in which persons become engrained into the condemnable justness system for long periods of their life. Farrell & A ; Calverley ( 2005 ) point out that important academic attending has been to this issue nevertheless the indispensable job remains unsolved, merely as with similar troubles which have developed in relation to welfare dependence. In the schoolroom exercising Irene suggested that she has spent a considerable sum of clip in the condemnable justness system and it is hence possible to propose that she has become accustomed to the system itself. Such continued exposure to condemnable justness processes creates a grade of acquaintance with the system which is unhelpful for long term declaration to offense related jobs.
As such, the fact that Irene is to a great extent engrained into the system must be accounted for in the appraisal in add-on to possible methods which could be adopted to decide the job. Krohn ( 2009 ) suggests that possible options to the traditional condemnable justness procedure could include a more outstanding function for societal services or occupational healers. Indeed, the usage of such professionals may function to efficaciously interrupt the rhythm which Irene is clearly in at the present occasion.The assorted treatments and appraisals undertaken supra have highlighted the indispensable issues associating to the appraisal of Irene.
What is clear is that Irene has relentless condemnable inclinations which day of the month back many decennaries. However, given that many of the offenses she has committed are low degree in nature, so the appraisal and pre-sentence study would profit from doing recommendations which avoid farther web in the condemnable justness system. Given that both the schoolroom exercising and the information on the instance itself highlight clear societal foundations for Irene ‘s behavior, so it is surely believable to propose that possible declaration to Irene ‘s condemnable actions could lie outside the traditional procedures of condemnable justness. Given the earnestness of the present offense, it is besides possible that a step of renewing justness could be adopted in a manner which shows Irene the wider effects of her actions.